3D printing may end product liability suits

Jan. 21, 2014

There is an interesting paper posted on the SSRN site by a Stanford law professor who concludes that 3D printing may make product liability suits obsolete. Nora Engstrom points out that product liability laws are aimed at commercial manufacturers, not hobbyists equipped with 3D printers. So if a part made by a hobbyist is somehow "defective" and causes injury, the injured party is basically out of luck. Engstrom also shows that suits against the maker of the 3D printer or against the "digital designer" who wrote the code that told the printer what to print would also probably not be successful. 

With regard to 3D printer makers, Engstrom says

"To prevail in such a suit, the plaintiff will have to show not simply that the printer churned out a defective product, but, instead, that the printer was itself defective. And, it’s not enough that the printer was defective at the time it printed the troublesome item—it must have been defective at the time it left the printer manufacturer’s possession and control. If the plaintiff can’t make this showing, a product liability suit is probably a nonstarter." 

The difficulty with suing the code designer, says Engstrom, is that, "just as strict liability law applies only to 'commercial sellers' and implicates only those items that are themselves 'defective,' it also applies only to 'products'— defined..... as 'tangible personal property.' And, though there’s some contrary authority, there are strong arguments that code does not qualify."

She sums up by speculating that "courts may well, in typical common law fashion, end up softening lines and blurring boundaries in order to impose strict liability on hobbyist 3D inventors and digital designers, especially if uncompensated injuries mount." 

Her essay is free on the SSRN site and can be downloaded here.

About the Author

Lee Teschler | Editor

Leland was Editor-in-Chief of Machine Design. He has 34 years of Service and holds a B.S. Engineering from the University of Michigan, a B.S. Electrical Engineering from the University of Michigan;, and a MBA from Cleveland State University. Prior to joining Penton, Lee worked as a Communications design engineer for the U.S. Government.

Sponsored Recommendations

Flexible Power and Energy Systems for the Evolving Factory

Aug. 29, 2024
Exploring industrial drives, power supplies, and energy solutions to reduce peak power usage and installation costs, & to promote overall system efficiency

Timber Recanting with SEW-EURODRIVE!

Aug. 29, 2024
SEW-EURODRIVE's VFDs and gearmotors enhance timber resawing by delivering precise, efficient cuts while reducing equipment stress. Upgrade your sawmill to improve safety, yield...

Advancing Automation with Linear Motors and Electric Cylinders

Aug. 28, 2024
With SEW‑EURODRIVE, you get first-class linear motors for applications that require direct translational movement.

Gear Up for the Toughest Jobs!

Aug. 28, 2024
Check out SEW-EURODRIVEs heavy-duty gear units, built to power through mining, cement, and steel challenges with ease!

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of Machine Design, create an account today!