Tips for choosing high-accuracy linear positioning systems: Part 2
The components that make up your high-accuracy positioning system — base and bearings, position-measuring system, motor-and-drive system, and controller — must work together as well as possible. In Part 1 ( PTD) we covered system base and bearings. Here, we cover position measurement. Part 3 will cover stage, drive, and encoder design; the drive amplifier; and controllers.
Position-measuring system
Generally, you can classify controllers as “open-loop” or “closed-loop.” With open-loop controllers (generally used with step motors) every impulse that the controller emits causes a certain slide displacement. However, there is no means to determine how large the displacement has been. For example, 500 pulses may have been emitted, but due to stiction, ball-screw tolerance, hysteresis, winding errors, and so forth, the table may have moved for only 498 pulses. A major disadvantage is that no positioning error correction occurs.
In a closed-loop system, or servo system, a position encoder provides feedback to the controller. The controller continues to send motor control signals until the exact desired position of the slide has been reached.
Figure 1 shows a slide with no position feedback in the upper illustration, followed by the three common methods for measuring slide position:
• Position encoder mounted on the motor or ball-screw shaft.
• Linear encoder mounted on the slide.
• Laser interferometer with mirrors mounted on the slide.
In the first method, slide position is measured indirectly — the position encoder mounts on the drive shaft. Tolerance, wear, and compliance in mechanical components between the slide and the position encoder lead to deviations between desired and true slide positions. Combined with the ball screw, slide accuracy at best is limited by ball-screw accuracy. Typical accuracies are ±5 to ±10 mm/300-mm travel.
Most linear measuring systems consist of an accurate glass scale and a photoelectric measuring head. Either the scale or the head attaches directly to the moving slide and measures slide position directly. Nor errors are introduced by ballscrew inaccuracies. Typical accuracies for the scale itself are ±1 to ±5 mm/m. This is also the accuracy of the slide itself at the measuring-head location.
The stage load (whose position accuracy is what we are really interested in) is always some distance from the measurement scale, measured in a direction perpendicular to the direction of movement, because most encoders are located under the slide, but the load is on top. This is even more pronounced with stacked stages. During a move, if the slide tilts somewhat because of deviations in straightness of the bearing ways, reversal errors, and so forth, a deviation relative to the position of the load vs. the encoder is created.
Dr. Ernst Abbé of Zeiss first described this error. Abbé error occurs when the measuring point of interest is displaced from the true measuring scale location, and when angular errors exist in the positioning system.* Abbé error makes the indicated position either shorter or longer than the true position, depending on the angular offset.
Abbé error =
(Offset distance) ×
(Tangent of offset angle)
If the angle is measured in radians then the equation is simply
Abbé error =(Angle) × (Offset)
Continue on page 2
A small angular error with a large offset, such as you find on stacked XY stages, can lead to multiplication of the scale inaccuracy. In other words, a measuring scale provides correct position information only at the site where the measuring head attaches.
A motion stage with precision roll characteristics, for example, shows typical angular errors of about ±5 arc sec. (1 arc sec = 1/3,600 deg or about 5 μrad.) For a distance of 100 mm between load and scale, this results in a positioning error of ±2.5 mm!
For extremely accurate applications, the laser-interferometer positioning feedback system with plane mirrors is the best choice. The wavelength of a helium- neon laser, 632.8 nm, serves as a standard. A nanometer is 1 × 10-9 meter. Accuracy of about ±0.1 mm/m for a stabilized laser source is possible, with resolution up to λ/1,024 or 0.617 μm. Lambda (λ) is the wavelength of light.
A main advantage is that the mirrors can be at the site of the load; that is, where the precision is truly important. Abbé errors are eliminated. Mirror flatness, typically in the submicron range, determines the linearity with which the slide moves.
In addition, because the motion for an XY stage is referenced to a fixed point outside the plane of motion, feedback compensates automatically for any out-of-squareness of the XY system (see Figure 2) because it keeps the slide at a fixed distance.
The wavelength of light in air depends on the speed of light in air, which is a function of air temperature, pressure, and relative humidity, among other things. When you use a measuring scale, a temperature change results in measurement errors because of expansion of the scale material. Typical expansion coefficients for glass and steel scales are 8 and 10 mm/m per deg K. With a laser interferometer, where a stable environment cannot be maintained, you can correct for atmospheric changes with optional automatic compensation components.
Figure 3 compares important properties of position-measuring systems.
Preston Miller is Senior Engineer, Anorad Corp., Hauppauge, N.Y. He holds a B.S. in Industrial Technology from Eastern Michigan University, and has 14 years’ experience in industrial controls and laser system design. Mat Lammers is Director of Anorad B.V., Valkenswaard, The Netherlands. He holds an M.S. in Mechanical Engineering from the University of Eindhoven, and has 9 years’ experience in the design and construction of high-accuracy air-bearing machines.
*For more about Abbé error, see PTD, “Precision XY Positioning: Tougher Demands Breed New Technologies,” 4/92, p. 37.