Not buying it: Walmart Manufacturing Fund too cheap

Today I got a press release from Walmart announcing a new program to fund innovations in U.S. manufacturing. It says the Walmart U.S. Manufacturing Innovation Fund is focused on the development and growth of U.S. But I don't think Walmart is.

Today I got a press release from Walmart announcing a new program to fund innovations in U.S. manufacturing. The summary sent with the release reads, “Walmart, the Walmart Foundation, and the United States Conference of Mayors (USCM) launched the Walmart U.S. Manufacturing Innovation Fund, focused on the development and growth of U.S. manufacturing, with a specific goal to make it both easier and more competitive to make household goods right here in the U.S. This initiative is part of Walmart and the Walmart Foundation’s broader commitment to investing in American jobs.”

Pardon me for being cynical and for slamming an easy punching bag — after all, Walmart has been easy to criticize at least since I wrote this article about the company in 2004 ...

Good buys (byes?) — Another look at what Chinese manufacturing means

But I'm just not buying the idea that the world's largest retailer and importer of goods from China is dedicated to investing in American jobs. After all, this is the company that held food drives last year ... for its employees.

Clearly, Walmart is banking on short memories and a wash of PR to improve its image among the doubters and shrugging shoppers alike.  I hate to say it, but that's probably a good bet.  And maybe the fund can do good: Non-profit organizations can apply for the grants — $100,000 or more — to "help create solutions to some of the biggest challenges with on-shoring and growing U.S. manufacturing."  That's no small change. Even so, Walmart's success as a low-cost import house still defines its primary identity. Here's a 2005 Machine Design editorial from Ron Kohl in which Kohl laments the impoverished existence we face if our future is driven by the lowest price of everything.

"Walmart is committed to American renewal and recently announced it will buy an additional $250 billion in U.S. products over the next 10 years in an effort to grow and expand U.S. manufacturing and encourage the creation of much needed U.S. jobs," continues the release summary. In fact, despite improving working conditions thanks in part to companies like Walmart, substandard work conditions remain in many industries.

So that I don't seem completely hostile to a company that is most certainly in my retirement accounts, I'm putting Walmart's full press release below.   But before I do that, here's a list of money the richest members of the Walton family have. In 2010, six members of the Walton family had the same wealth as the bottom 42% of American families combined. Information courtesy Forbes 400 list and

Compare and contrast these numbers to those in the Innovation Fund at your leisure.

Christy Walton — Net worth $36.7 billion

Jim Walton — Net worth $34.7 billion

Alice Walton — Net worth $34.3 billion

Rob Walton — Net worth $34.2 billion

Ann Walton Kroenke — Net worth $4.8 billion

Nancy Walton Laurie — Net worth $4.1 billion


Walmart, Walmart Foundation and the U.S. Conference of Mayors Launch $10 Million U.S. Manufacturing Innovation Fund

Grants to advance innovative solutions to increase U.S. manufacturing

EMBARGOED until 2 p.m. EST - Washington, D.C. – March 13, 2014 - Walmart, the Walmart Foundation and the United States Conference of Mayors (USCM) today launched the Walmart U.S. Manufacturing Innovation Fund. Eligible non-profit organizations can apply for grants of $100,000 or more, funded by the Walmart Foundation, to help create solutions to challenges many companies face with on-shoring and growing U.S. manufacturing.

The first year of the initiative will focus on innovation in textiles manufacturing and common manufacturing processes that apply to a broad range of consumer goods, including small motor manufacturing and tooling for injection molding. Anticipated participating organizations include research and academic institutions, think tanks and other non-profit entities focused on innovations in manufacturing.

“Through the Walmart U.S. Manufacturing Innovation Fund, we hope to help remove the barriers to revitalizing and growing U.S. manufacturing, creating jobs and building a stronger American economy,” said Cindi Marsiglio, vice president of U.S. sourcing and domestic manufacturing for Walmart. “This is part of Walmart and the Walmart Foundation’s broader commitment to foster new ideas and jobs to promote strong communities and grow America’s manufacturing footprint.”

Today’s announcement is part of Walmart's commitment to buy an additional $250 billion in products that support American manufacturing. It represents a significant investment to accelerate U.S. manufacturing and create American jobs. The Boston Consulting Group estimates the initiative will add 1 million jobs in the United States.

"The U.S. Conference of Mayors is committed to helping bring manufacturing jobs back to America's cities, and our partnership with Walmart and the Walmart Foundation will strengthen our metro economies that drive the national economy," said Tom Cochran, USCM CEO and executive director.

Applications are due April 22, 2014. Selected proposals will receive grants ranging from $100,000 and above for award periods of at least one year, with the option of reapplying for continued funding. Each applicant will need sponsorship from the mayor of a USCM member city.

For more information and to apply for a grant please visit


In conclusion (and this isn't part of the release) here's another Comedy Central Walmart commentary for the heck of it:



Discuss this Blog Entry 2

on Mar 18, 2014

Pull out your dusty Eighties copies of "Japan Inc." Sounds a lot like the corporate pyramids used there, doesn't it: how the Japanese corporations at the pinnacles were / are supported by networks of [their own] vendors at the underside of the same pyramid.

on Mar 18, 2014

Yeah, Walmart's "fund" is just phony PR but that's just the actions of a single company. What bothers me much more is we're telling our high school students that "STEM" jobs (including engineering) are just GOING BEGGING out there and we're encouraging them to enter all manner of science fairs and robotics competitions to "pique their interest". What we're NOT telling them is after they commit to this field of study and start loking for work, as soon as any kind of job in this field pops up, the company in need goes to DC and gets another H1B visa and brings someone in from overseas at minimum wage to fill it and just about DARES anyone to try and undercut it - wait, you can;t afford to live on that! Now THAT is total hypocrisy, I guess the teachers' unions want to see much more money poured into these equally phony "STEM education initiatives". But it's suddenly become a national obsession to see which field can lay claim to the title of displaying the biggest hypocrisy while our children suffer. Why won't anyone even TALK about this??

Please or Register to post comments.

What's Product Design Engineering?

Existing and emerging technologies immediately applicable to product design, as well as industry trends that promise to change engineering.


Elisabeth Eitel

Elisabeth is Senior Editor of Machine Design magazine. She has a B.S. in Mechanical Engineering from Fenn College at Cleveland State University. Over the last decade, Elisabeth has worked as a...
Blog Archive
Connect With Us

Sponsored Introduction Continue on to (or wait seconds) ×