My Site
Skip to Content

Computers for MCAD

July 7, 2011

Leslie Gordon

High- end PCs versus entry- level workstations.

Printer-friendly version

Authored by:
Renganathan Subramanyam
Worldwide Product Manager, Entry Workstations
Hewlett-Packard
Fort Collins, Colo.
Resources:
Hewlett-Packard

Edited by Leslie Gordon,
leslie.gordon@penton.com

How do high-end business PCs differ from entry-level workstations? What, if any, additional value do workstations bring to MCAD applications? The best way to get a handle on these common concerns is to first define “workstation.”

In general, a workstation is a computer with more specialized capabilities than a desktop PC. For example, workstations feature higher-performance processors, professional-grade 3D graphics, and more expansion slots for adding memory, graphics capabilities, or support for special devices. Workstations use powerful processors and error-correcting code (ECC) memory. In addition, workstations are certified by independent software vendors (ISV) for MCAD and other applications. Workstation vendors like Hewlett-Packard (HP), Palo Alto, Calif., rigorously test hardware platforms and software stacks to ensure reliability and performance.

Workstations also include features that are not found on a PC such as the HP Performance Advisor on the new HP Z210. It lets users easily configure, customize, and optimize the system for each new software program and driver installed. HP Performance Advisor also organizes configuration information, which streamlines the decision-making process for loading the latest drivers and up dates. In the case of any problems, Autodesk, San Rafael, Calif., and SolidWorks, Concord, Mass., support staff can review HP Performance Advisor configuration reports to provide better service and support.

Comments

SolidWorks Productivity with Workstations

SPECapc for SolidWorks can be found in the website http://www.spec.org/gwpg/apc.static/sw2007.html This provides a comprehensive set of tools to evaluate CPU, Graphics and Data I/O benchmarks. We have found that a workstation (even entry level) has a better performance in comparison to a desktop, on account of the following reasons:
1. Processor over-clocking
2. Motherboard configuration specifically designed for performance
3. Minimized wait states for CPU
4. BIOS Settings
5. ECC vs Non-ECC RAM
6. Graphics Card (OpenGL certified) and Drivers
7. Memory capacity, type and bank loading (for example 2X4GB DIMMs will be better than 4x2GB DIMMs for a total of 8GB RAM)
8. No. of Z-Buffering planes
9. Cooling Configuration
10. OS type (Professional or Home Editions of Windows)

When performing Spec comparison, differentials in terms of percentage should be considered instead of values.

It is worth the cost, especially with i7 processors being replaced by Intel Xeon these days for same or lesser costs.

Natarajan R.
EGS Computers India Private Limited
Engineering Design Services & SolidWorks Reseller in India
Offices: Chennai * Coimbatore * Trichy

Leave a comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Acceptable Use Policy