Travis Ayers
Product Manager
Small Precision Tools
Petaluma, Calif.
www.A1.sptca.com

Comparison of common items and MicroCIM features.

Automated inspection of internal features in normally opaque alumina.

This CIM catheter weighs 0.0004 gm and has wall sections 0.0035-in. thick. The alumina catheter, together with surface-mount circuitry, produces sonogram images.

Ceramic injection-molded orthodontic brackets weigh 0.1 gm and have tolerances of 0.025 mm (scale is cm). They are produced in translucent 99.99% alumina to better match the color of teeth.



Compared to heavy-duty processes used to make bulky injection-molded ceramic spark plugs in the 1930s, today's sophisticated ceramic injection-molding (CIM) technology can produce microminiature components with features as small as 18 µm (0.0007 in.). MicroCIM parts weighing as little as 0.0004 gm serve in a wide variety of applications where high temperatures and caustic environments preclude most metals and engineered thermoplastics.

Components boasting intricate, 18-µm features, including through holes, gear teeth, and screw threads, are well suited for microCIM molding. It can also turn out components with whisper-thin, 25-µm (0.001-in.) cross sections and those needing consistent, single-micron dimensional tolerances. In spite of its capabilities, many designers are unaware of CIM's ability to produce microminiature parts that would be difficult, costly, or impossible to form through traditional processes.

CIM basics

CIM is a combination of particulate materials, injection molding, and sintering science. Submicron ceramic powder is one key to microminiature molding. Powder selection is based on several factors including particle size, shape, and distribution. Under carefully monitored conditions, powders are blended with proprietary binders and additives, giving the mixture the fluidity to consistently fill finely detailed molds similar to those in traditional plastic-injection molding. Production CIM tooling, however, must be made from hardened materials to better resist the highly abrasive ceramic powders and requires tighter tolerances.

Depending on the application, tooling can be single or multicavity. Slides, cores, and other common tooling techniques for plastic injection molding are also used. To minimize up-front costs, molders often use different prototype building techniques to finalize part configurations before building production tooling. Common prototype methods range from machining components to using rapid-prototype tooling to produce injection-molded test pieces.

Injection-molding machines modified for CIM heat the feedstock and inject it into the mold. Parts solidify and are ejected from the mold as "green." Green parts are oversized and somewhat fragile. Technicians can inspect internal features with an in-process monitoring system, even in opaque materials, before parts are fired. This gives designers real-time feedback, reduces production costs, and ultimately improves quality.

After inspection, green parts are debound through evaporation and exothermic reactions that remove all but a small fraction of the binder. Parts then undergo prolonged exposure to temperatures up to 1,800° C in sintering furnaces. Sintering consolidates the powder just below the melting point of the ceramic constituents. During solid-state diffusionary processes, atoms and molecules migrate through the ceramic via a mass-transport mechanism of either lattice diffusion, surface diffusion, or evaporation-condensation. Sintering furnaces must be tailored with either oxidizing or reducing atmospheres that match the diffusionary mechanism of each ceramic. As ceramic particles fuse together, part dimensions predictably shrink around 20% and part density increases. Upon sintering, surface finish of 8 rms can readily be achieved.

For certain applications, CIM parts undergo a second hot-isostatic pressing (HIP) process that boosts the ceramic density and strength. CIM parts are small, so the secondary HIPing process doesn't appreciably increase part costs.

CIM produces net-shape parts. But for applications demanding exacting surface finishes or precision beyond as-sintered capabilities, finishing operations similar to those used for ultra-hard materials are required. These may include diamond grinding, lapping, or honing.

Material selection

There is a wide array of technical ceramics available. Here are a few of those most commonly used for microminiature components.

Aluminum oxide or alumina (Al2O3) is the most widely used and cost-effective engineered ceramic. It comes in several crystalline structures. Hexagonal alpha phase is the most stable at high temperatures. Alpha-phase alumina is the strongest and stiffest oxide ceramic. It also has good dielectric properties, resists most reagents except hydrofluoric and phosphoric acid, has good thermal properties, and high hardness. Alumina lacks fracture toughness, which can limit its use in structural applications under tension. However, it is important to note that alumina, for example, can perform well in tension. It has three to five times the tensile strength of many plastics, and half that of 316 stainless steel.

Zirconia (ZrO2) has a high melting point (2,700° C), low thermal conductivity, and is not as hard as alumina. It exists in three crystalline forms: cubic, tetragonal, and monoclinic. At high temperatures zirconia undergoes phase transformations which reduce its mechanical properties and limit its use as an engineered ceramic. However, doping or alloying zirconia with oxides, such as CaO, MgO, and Y2O3, fully or partially stabilizes it. The resulting ceramics no longer undergo phase transformation during heating and cooling. Stabilized zirconia can also be heat treated (transformation toughened) to produce an intragranular tetragonal-zirconia precipitate which compressively stresses the entire structure and increases fracture toughness and bending strength.

Fully stabilized zirconia is harder and better resists thermal shock. It also has higher oxygen-ion conductivity, so it is used in oxygen sensors and solid-oxide fuel cells. Partially stabilized zirconia (PSZ), on the other hand, is a mixture of both cubic and tetragonal ZrO2 crystals. Its bending strength rivals that of hardened tool steel. It also holds a sharp edge so it finds use in industrial and domestic knives and surgical scalpels.

Zirconia toughened alumina (ZTA) combines alumina's high hardness and wear properties with zirconia's toughness and bending strength. ZTA has over a threefold increase in flexural strength over high purity (99.99%) alumina and double that of ZrO2.

Polycrystalline ruby (Al2O3 + Cr2O3) is a translucent alumina ceramic that gets its distinctive red hue from CrO3 (about 1% of Al3+ is replaced by Cr3+). Polycrystalline ruby is inert, biocompatible, and resists wear, heat, and acids. It is slightly harder than high-purity (99.99%) alumina.

Designing for CIM

Designers familiar with plastic injection-molding principles have a head start on designing for CIM. In general, CIM parts tend to have:

  • Minimized, consistent wall sections.
  • Gradual transitions (Avoid sharp corners).
  • Allowances for parting lines, gate vestige, ejector pin marks, and draft angles.
  • Designs optimized for minimal mass.
  • Complex features.
  • Production volumes of >10,000 parts/yr.

The design and manufacture of custom CIM components requires close cooperation between designers and molders. As with many technologies, early supplier involvement carries many advantages, including reduced lead times and lower overall costs. Partnering with experienced CIM vendors also lets designers tailor components to take maximum advantage of CIM processing.

It's important to submit CAD models, sketches, or drawings early in the design process to see if the components are compatible with CIM. That's because it may be more economical to produce simple shapes with traditional manufacturing techniques. In general, the more complex, the more advantage CIM has over other methods. Annual quantities, critical dimensions, function, and allowances for molding features (gate, ejector pins, and parting lines) are other factors that influence whether or not CIM is a suitable manufacturing option.

Based on technical specifications, project complexity, and urgency of the request, quotations may take anywhere from 24 hr to 2 weeks. Quotes should include additional provisions for non-recurring engineering charges, and tooling (both mold tooling and sintering fixtures if required).

Designers looking to experiment with component variations will also be quoted on various prototyping options including machining and rapid-prototype tooling.

Once tooling is complete, initial samples are inspected against the customer's drawing. At this time, dimensions on the drawing may have to be altered to meet the sample or the tooling may be revised. If the tooling is changed, a second set of samples are molded and inspected against the print.

CIM is a very repeatable manufacturing process that is best suited to high-volume components that are difficult, costly, or impractical to produce via traditional techniques. CIM is a net-shape process that offers designers the advantages of ultra-hard materials without the costs associated with other manufacturing methods. Partnering with a well-established CIM firm will allow engineers to take full advantage of the process, while minimizing lead time and costs.




Inspecting green parts

Designers tasked with making CIM parts with tapered inside diameters of 0.001 in. soon find that the parts will be a challenge to manufacture and require careful process controls. With additional concentricity specs that require the entire tapered holes to be 4-µm (0.00016-in.) total indicator reading (TIR), the task takes on a new level of complexity. Inspecting these features to these specifications is often a tricky task.

Historically, CIM features could not be accurately measured until after the part was sintered. "Green" (as-molded) parts are fragile enough that fine features can't be accurately or repeatedly sectioned and measured. It typically took five working days for designers to get feedback on measurements of sintered parts.

There's a new method for performing inspection without waiting for the sintered product. It uses optics and precise measurement equipment to measure a variety of internal configurations. Such systems let molding operators see inside the opaque CIM parts immediately after molding. It also takes automatic measurement readings and records data for statistical-process control (SPC).

Engineering teams continue to use a combination of mechanical, electrical, and software-design techniques in developing ways to automate inspection. This includes using scanning-electron microscopy at 2,500X to inspect parts with tolerances on the order of <2 µm. The key benefits of in-process inspection include increased yields and throughputs, reduced inventories, tooling and process enhancements, and lower costs.




  ALUMINA ZIRCONIA
Mechanical properties Al2O3
99.7%
Al2O3
99.99%
Polycrystalline ruby
Al2O3 + Cr2O3
Zirconia toughened alumina
(ZTA) (90% Al2O3 + 10% ZrO2)
Zirconia
ZrO2
Zirconia alumina
(80% ZrO2 + 20% Al2O3)
ESD Zirconia
(ZrO2 + doping)
Density, gm/cm2 >3.9 >3.98 >3.9 >4.25 >6.0 - >6.0
Color White
(translucent
available)
White
(translucent
available)
Red
(translucent
available)
White Ivory
or
Black
White Black
Flexural strength, MPa 310 340 360 500 1,000 2,200 -
Compressive strength, MPa 3,200 3,700 3,700 2,000 1,850 - -
Hardness, HV1 1,800 2,100 2,200 2,000 1,400 1,500 1,100
Grain size, µm <10 <5 <2 <0.5 <0.5 - -
Characteristics - - - - - - Electrostatic dissipative
1010 Ohm-cm
Applications RF and electrical insulators, wear components, wire guides, orthodontic brackets, dental implants, precision dispensing nozzles Textile thread guides, sensor covers, wear-resistant nozzles, precision watch gears Bushings, bearings, metal-forming components, cutting tools, pump pistons Cutting blades, pump components, oxygen sensors, dental screws, electrosurgical insulators, valve seals Endoscopic cutters, thin-wall catheter tips, tweezers, semiconductor wire bonding tips Semiconductor tooling, electronic assembly, hard disc drive assembly, applications where dissipation of static electricity is important