Original Publish Date : 8/4/2008
Leland Tecshler's Editorial: What’s hot? Not ethanol
This special issue looks at some of the technologies and industrial themes that are eliciting a lot of interest in the technical community.

But perhaps more interesting than some of the “hot” technologies we review is what you won’t find here: any discussion of ethanol.

January’s North American International Auto Show could well have conveyed the idea that ethanol-based fuel would have been a hot topic this year. Amongst much hoopla, carmakers introduced vehicle after vehicle that could run on E85. Even Ferrari showed off an E85-mobile.

Veteran automotive analysts were unimpressed by this onslaught of E85 exuberance. They knew the real reason Detroit was so keen on ethanol: By producing flex-fuel vehicles, automakers can artificially boost the fuelefficiency numbers they must meet under Corporate Average Fuel Economy standards. That’s because for CAFE, the federal government counts only the amount of gasoline a vehicle consumes getting from point A to B and ignores any ethanol it burns on the trip. A flex-fuel SUV, for example, might get city mileage of about 14 mpg on pure gasoline. But for purposes of CAFE, it is assumed to be running on E85. So on paper the SUV gets about 29 mpg of gasoline in the city.

Of course, most such behemoths will rarely pull up to an E85 pump. So the 29-mpg rating is more myth than reality.

And odds are Las Vegas will become a city of teetotalers before today’s ethanol processes will replace a significant amount of petroleum-based fuels. The basic problem is a lack of heat energy in the feedstock. Crude oil contains about 18,400 Btu/lb; coal, 10,400 Btu/lb. But corn comes in at 7,000 Btu/lb. Switchgrass, billed as the next great hope for ethanol feedstock, has only 6,400 Btu/lb.

The low heat energy of switchgrass means no matter how efficient the refining process, mind-boggling amounts of the stuff are necessary to produce meaningful quantities of ethanol. To see this in real terms, consider an informal exercise cited by energy journalist Robert Bryce. Based on U.S. DOE estimates, a plant able to produce 80 million gallons of ethanol annually would need to take in 1 million tons of corn stubble. That much stubble would take up 67,000 semitrailers. Put another way, that is 187 semitruckloads a day. The plant’s annual output of ethanol would be the equivalent of 53 million gallons of gasoline, or just 0.04% of the U.S. annual gasoline consumption.

But what about biodiesel refined from algae? It’s not clear algae-based biofuel is economically practical. As with switchgrass, you need a lot of pond scum to get much fuel. Researchers at the University of New Hampshire estimate it would take between 9.5 and 28.5 million acres of land, depending on your assumptions, to produce enough algae for U.S. transportation fuel needs. Raising algae in bioreactors is another option, but the cost for meaningful outputs quickly gets into the eyes-glaze-over range.

The best that can be said is that the jury is still out on whether you’ll see algae biofuels in a future “hot” issue.

But enough about that. Readers of our print and digital editions will probably notice Machine Design has a new look. We’ve updated our graphics and introduced a few new features aimed at forging a closer link between the print magazine and machinedesign.com. It’s all in the interest of better serving our readers.

— Leland Teschler, Editor

Rate / Comment on this Article

Post a comment

Be the first to comment on this article

Login to post a comment
Jamison RFID Portals
Jamison's Industrial Portals Division produces heavy-duty RFID portals that are custom designed enclosures that help track products during the manufacturing process and throughout the entire supply chain. Industrial Portals design allows users to easily install and integrate any RFID hardware/software systems with dramatically lower costs than other systems.
Higgs-3 Integrated Circuit
The Alien Technology Higgs is a family of highly integrated single chip UHF RFID Tag ICs. The chips conform to the EPCglobal Class 1 Gen 2 specifications and provide state-of-the-art performance for a broad range of UHF RFID tagging applications. Higgs-3 builds on that performance foundation by offering enhanced authentication and security capabilities along with extended memory and EPC number features....
Alien Technology RFID
As RFID expands into more applications, the simple knowledge that a given tag was seen at a certain read point is sometimes inadequate. For some applications we’d like to know more. Was the tag moving or stationary? Which direction? How fast? How far away? Alien Technology's new Intelligent Tag Radar (ITR) provides this and other information about the tag. This capability enables the RFID...
New Analog to Digital Converter Technology
From the labs at Analog Devices comes a new technology in analog to digital converter technology that is the culmination of three years work. In this episode, Bill Scofield, Design Group Leader, explains the new continuous time sigma delta converter that uses an internal loop filter with no switch capacitor sampler section.
RFID "Sniffer" Architecture
As RFID adoption continues to grow, engineers are faced with an increasing need to validate tags both for interoperability with products from other vendors and for conformance with the specified protocol. The "sniffer" RFID tag test system uses a vector signal analyzer to “sniff” the air interface between an interrogator and a tag. This system uses a reference “gold” reader or RFID simulator...
The blame game
I feel there was a glaring omission in Mr. Berke's May 25, 2006 column titled "For lack of a guard, a severed hand" — personal responsibility.
Shake, rattle, and modal analysis
FEA can be a useful tool for sizing up resonance problems.
Biomimetics could hold a key to next-generation body armor
Who would have thought that your wife's jewelry holds the secret to better body armor?
What's a mechatronics technician?
When Keith Campbell muses about industrial education, his thoughts go back to his uncle Ralph.
The meaning of bearing life
How long will a bearing last? Standardized life equations help to answer.
Engineering an ad
How do you convince a doubting public your truck is tough? You show them.
Tricked-Out Trucks
Stylists and engineers are exploring new ways to personalize pickup trucks, the best-selling type of vehicle in the U.S.
Tom-Thumb turbines power radio-controlled jets
Engineers have managed to shrink the modern jet engine until it is small enough to fit in model planes.
Engineering in India
Here’s a snapshot of the Indian engineers who increasingly compete for global manufacturing work.
Gulliver's Engines
Shrinking full-scale engines to pocket size is no small feat.
PRODUCT SEARCH
Powered by
SEARCH THE PLASTICS WEB™
Powered by
FORUMS
Where are the Lighting/lamp engineers and designers?
Are you looking for some Industrial deisgners? We have got good experience in designing lamps using latest LED technology. You can contact me if you haven't...

Making metallic objects when only a physical part is available
Hi Leslie: If the object is small, I wonder if the dental industry might suggest a solution.  I worked as a dental tech and we used the icky polymer...

Trustworthy engineer needed
Hi,Did you find the resource? 

Lead shot making
I have been using liquid laundry detergent as a coolant and having grate success. The one I use is the cheapest that can be found and it is from the dollar...

Need Mech. Designer as a equal partner
We are the NOVA group and we’re a start-up company in the New York area. We will be producing parts for the auto industry We are looking for a Mech. Designer...