How do you halve the price of a
passenger car? It takes more than
savvy negotiations at the dealership.
In 2004, Tata Motors took
on the challenge of bringing a
100,000-rupee ($2,500) car to the
Indian market. Tata’s closest competitor,
the Maruti 800 retails for
about $5,000. The result of Tata’s
efforts, the Nano, was unveiled in
January 2008 and will reach consumers
in October.
Tata has squeezed low prices out
of its suppliers with high-volume,
single-source contracts. About
100 suppliers will build 90% of
the Nano’s parts, three-quarters of
which are single-sourced.
The initial production plan of
250,000 to 350,000 units/yr was
tempting enough, but rumors have
surfaced that this could quickly double.
Tata’s CEO Ratan Tata has said
he hopes to build additional factories
elsewhere in India or sell Nano kits
to entrepreneurs to hit a total production
of 1 million units/yr.
“A bunch of entrepreneurs could
establish an assembly operation
and Tata Motors would train their
people, oversee their quality assurance,
and they would become satellite
assembly operations for us.
So we would create entrepreneurs
across the country that would produce
the car. We would produce
the mass items and ship them as
kits,” Tata told the Times of India.
The chosen suppliers are moving
quickly to build new factories,
colocated with the new Tata factory
in Singur, West Bengal. The
savings in transport costs and inter-
state taxes, coupled with low labor
costs, have sweetened the deal.
Work is moving ahead despite local
protests about the conversion
of farmland to industrial use.
In many cases Tata has worked
with suppliers to replace conventional
manufacturing processes
with faster, cheaper methods. Hydroformed
tubes will replace solid
bar-stock in the body frame and
steering column. Body panels will
be roll-formed instead of pressed.
Improving up-front quality to
a defect target of 100 ppm was another
focus. The Caparo Group,
noted in the U.K. for its T1 hyper car, has a zero-defect strategy for
building the Nano’s inner structural
panels in Singur.
“The body technology is relatively
conventional, but the manufacturing
technology is the result
of sophisticated analysis to ensure
high-quality, low-cost production,”
CEO Angad Paul says.
Other savings came from examining
cars from the ground up and
stripping out unnecessary features.
German engine-electronics company
Robert Bosch GmbH designed
the single multipoint fuel injector for
the Nano’s two-cylinder, single-overhead-
cam engine. The unit is controlled
by a stripped-down version
of the company’s Motronic engine
control unit.
“Low-price vehicles are not vehicles
of inferior quality equipped
with the most basic components.
Instead, they are inexpensive
technical solutions produced using
state-of-the-art components.
They are tailored exactly to customer
and regional needs,” said
Wolf-Henning Scheider, president
of Robert Bosch’s Gasoline Systems Div. in a June 2007 speech.
The engine itself is stripped
down to bare bones. Its two Federal-
Mogul Goetze pistons are
served by a single Amtek balancer
shaft, making it the first engine of its
type. The 623-cc engine produces
only 33 hp, less than one-third of
the power available in U.S.-market
subcompacts. The car’s top speed is
about 65 mph, but little driving in
India is at highway speeds.
However, fuel efficiency
47 mpg, according to Tata’s claims
is a stronger selling point in India’s
emerging market than highspeed
performance. That fuel efficiency
provides a 188-mile range
on a full 4-gallon tank of gasoline.
Considering the tank sits directly
under the passenger seat, the
skimpy capacity could be viewed as
a safety measure. The fueling point
is under the car’s hood, which
cuts out the extra steps and parts
needed for a side fuel door.
Weight reduction was essential
to get performance out of the tiny
engine. A heavy driveshaft and
attendant safety measures were
eliminated by moving the reardrive
engine aft. The structure was
stiffened without adding weight
by using tubular framing, designing
internal parts like seat risers to
lend structural support, and adding
ribs to the roof panels. The rear
panel and window are welded shut
for further stiffness, with the tradeoff
that drivers must fold down the
rear seat from inside the car to access
the engine.
Reducing weight in those areas
scaled back the steering linkage
and front suspension (MacPherson
struts with lower A-arms),
saving additional weight. The rear
suspension features relatively beefy
coil springs to cushion the effects
of a 30:70 rear weight bias. The
2.5-in-wide tubeless tires, supplied
by JK Tyre, are 12-in. diameter in
the front and 13-in. diameter in
the rear. All the wheels have been
placed at the corners to improve
handling.
Instead of ducting air from a front
grille toward the rear engine,
the air intake is behind the back
doors. This leaves a little leg room
and about 5.3 cu ft of cargo space
up front, but further unbalances the
weight distribution toward the rear.
Little changes have been made
elsewhere to delete nonessential
components. Actuators that keep
headlights level when the car hits
a bump were removed, famously
saving $10/car. Disc brakes were replaced
with drum units and power
boosters were removed. Other notable
omissions are a second windshield
wiper, a passenger sun visor,
a glove box, rear-seat belts, and a
fourth lug nut on each wheel.
The instrument panel, designed
and produced by Delphi India,
contains only an odometer, fuel
gage, analog speedometer, and
turn-signal indicators. There is no
tachometer. With extensive acoustic
insulation outside Nano’s budget,
the resonance of the sheet metal at
around 5,000 rpm provides its own
reminder to shift.
The front console is also missing
the audio system ubiquitous in U.S.
cars. A radio can be added as part of
the luxury package. Other features
U.S. drivers take for granted, like
automatic transmission, power windows
and locks, and air conditioning,
are only available by upgrade.
Power steering is not in the plans,
but with a curb weight of about
1,300 lb it’s probably not needed.
Tata has admitted to a near-zero
profit margin on this model. It
hopes to regain ground on deluxe
and luxury models. Buyers can also
pay extra to customize their Nano
with alloy wheels, fog lamps, sports
scoops, decals, colored bumpers,
and cloth seat covers.
Future models may be available
with electric engines or with fuel
systems that accommodate natural
gas, biofuels, and flex fuels. A diesel
engine is already in the works, as is a
continuously variable transmission.
Further upgrades like back-seat
safety belts, air bags, and beefier
body panels would be required to
meet European or U.S. safety regulations.
Long-range plans for the
Nano call for it to be rolled out to
emerging markets in Asia, Africa,
and South America in the next four
years.
MAKE CONTACT
Amtek, amtek.com
Caparo Group, caparo.com
Federal-Mogul Goetze India,
federalmogulgoetzeindia.net
JK Tyre, jktyre.com
Robert Bosch GmbH,
rb-k.bosch.de/en
Tata Motors, tatamotors.com