Making sure brakes don’t break
Q: What’s the difference between stopping dynamically and holding a load with power-off brakes? How do I correctly size a power-off brake?
Rocco Dragone
Thomson Deltran Product Specialist
Danaher Motion Corp.
A: In last month’s column we ended with the
formula used to estimate the torque needed to
dynamically stop the load in an interval of time. Once the
torque value is determined, multiply the result by 1.25 (25%)
to obtain a minimum static torque. The deceleration time
plus the brake-engage time must be less than or equal to the
desired stopping time.
You’ll need to consider total energy absorption (energy
dissipation). You must verify that the brake can dissipate the
amount of kinetic energy that it absorbs per cycle for as long
as it takes to perform the entire operation. Repeated cycling
builds up heat, which the brake must be able to withstand
continuously.
Total energy dissipation is typically expressed in units of
ft-lb. It is defined as the sum of the dissipated kinetic energy
Ek and slip energy Es. Kinetic-energy dissipation Ek is:
Ek = 4.6 10-4 I ω″
where I = total system moment of inertia, lb-in.-sec″, and ω =
rotational speed, rpm. Slip-energy dissipation Es is:
Es = 43.6 10 4 ω D Ts
where Ts = total slip time, seconds, and D = load drag torque
in the system, lb-in.
Compare the calculated values of energy-per-cycle and
energy-per-minute with the values in the manufacturer’s
product data sheets. The calculated values should be equal
to or less than the catalog ratings to ensure the brakes have a
long lifetime.
It is important to note that all power-off spring-set brakes
are designed primarily for use in static-holding systems.
Wear factors for friction materials are more critical when the
brakes work in the dynamic stopping mode. Applications
calling for repeated dynamic stopping may necessitate use of
different friction material better suited to high heat and wear
situations.
Rocco Dragone is a Thomson Deltran Product Specialist
with Danaher Motion Corp. Got a question about motion
control or mechatronics? Ask Rocco via e-mail at Editorial@
DanaherMotion.com.